Two ways of looking at Melbourne's past
Fitzroy 1974 and Old Vintage Melbourne both use photography to explore Melbourne's history, but they do very different jobs. Fitzroy 1974 revisits Robert Ashton's 1974 black-and-white series documenting life in the suburb of Fitzroy, republished with new writing edited by novelist Gregory Day. Old Vintage Melbourne is a collection of annotated historical images and contemporary photographs that traces the city's development from John Batman's 1835 diary entry ('This will be the place for a village') to the modern city, including then-and-now contrasts.
If you are choosing between them, the decision comes down to scope and format: a focused, single-suburb documentary project in black and white, or a broader city-wide survey that pairs past and present views.
What each book contains
- Fitzroy 1974: Fitzroy 1974 presents Robert Ashton's 1974 black-and-white image series documenting life in Fitzroy, first published as Into the Hollow Mountains, with new writing edited by Gregory Day. 184 pages; 29.5cm x 24cm. This tells you the book is a concentrated documentary record of one suburb at a specific moment, not a general Melbourne history. The page count and dimensions also help you judge whether it is a substantial reference or a lighter browse.

Fitzroy 1974 - Old Vintage Melbourne Original Edition: Old Vintage Melbourne is an enchanting collection of annotated historical images and contemporary photographs, revealing the change and development Melbourne has experienced over the years, with then-and-now photographs contrasting past and present. This describes a city-wide, comparative approach: you see historical views alongside contemporary ones, which suits readers interested in how Melbourne has changed rather than a single neighbourhood.

Old Vintage Melbourne Original Edition
How the two books differ in scope and approach
The comparison below is based only on the supplied catalog information. Neither book's full contents or exact reproduction quality can be judged from these records, so treat this as a guide to intent and format, not a verdict on print quality.
- Geographic focus: Fitzroy 1974 is dedicated to the suburb of Fitzroy. Old Vintage Melbourne covers the city of Melbourne broadly, from its 1835 origins to the present day.
- Time period: Fitzroy 1974 centres on 1974, with new writing added fifty years on. Old Vintage Melbourne spans more than a century, using annotated historical images and contemporary photographs.
- Photographic approach: Fitzroy 1974 is a black-and-white documentary series by one photographer. Old Vintage Melbourne combines historical images with contemporary photographs, including then-and-now pairs.
- Page count and size: Fitzroy 1974 is 184 pages and measures 29.5cm x 24cm. The supplied record for Old Vintage Melbourne does not include page count or dimensions, so a direct physical comparison is not possible from this evidence.
- Editorial context: Fitzroy 1974 includes new writing edited by Gregory Day and original writing from local creatives in the earlier edition. Old Vintage Melbourne is adapted from the popular Old Vintage Melbourne Instagram account and features annotated images.
What Fitzroy 1974 documents
The supplied description of Fitzroy 1974 paints a detailed picture of the suburb in the 1970s: bluestone lanes, hard-case pubs, high-rise commission flats, and a mix of communities including First Nations people from the Kulin nation and beyond, alongside churches, the Divine Light Mission, student flop houses and industrial sweat shops. It also notes that Fitzroy became a haven for painters, musicians, writers and photographers chasing cheap rent, driving a creative legacy compared in the text to Greenwich Village and Montmartre.
That level of detail suggests a book for readers who want an immersive, place-specific documentary record. The black-and-white photographs are by Robert Ashton, and the series was first published in 1974 as Into the Hollow Mountains. This edition presents that work with new writing, making it both a historical document and a contemporary reflection.
What Old Vintage Melbourne covers
Old Vintage Melbourne takes a broader, more comparative approach. It uses annotated historical images and contemporary photographs to show how the city has changed, with then-and-now pairs that let you see the same locations across time. The book invites you to imagine strolling down Bourke Street in 1875, catching a Collins Street tram in 1910, or walking through inner suburbs years ago.
Because it is adapted from an Instagram account, the tone is likely to be accessible and visual, but the supplied information does not confirm the balance of text to images or the number of photographs. What is clear is that the book is organised around the contrast between past and present Melbourne, rather than a single neighbourhood.
Which book suits which reader
Use these pairings as a starting point, based on the documented scope of each book.
- You want a deep dive into one suburb: Fitzroy 1974 offers a concentrated look at Fitzroy in the 1970s, with a single photographer's black-and-white series and new editorial writing. It is the stronger choice if you are researching Fitzroy specifically or are drawn to documentary photography of a defined place and time.
- You want a city-wide overview with then-and-now comparisons: Old Vintage Melbourne covers the city as a whole and explicitly pairs historical images with contemporary photographs. It suits readers interested in urban change across Melbourne rather than one neighbourhood.
- You are buying as a gift for someone who knows Melbourne: Both books trade on local recognition, but Old Vintage Melbourne's broad landmarks (Bourke Street, Collins Street) may resonate more widely, while Fitzroy 1974 will particularly appeal to anyone with a connection to Fitzroy or an interest in 1970s Australian photography.
- You need to know the physical size before buying: Fitzroy 1974 is listed at 29.5cm x 24cm. The supplied record for Old Vintage Melbourne does not include dimensions or page count, so if shelf fit or heft matters, check the product page or ask before ordering.
What the records do not tell you
Neither book's supplied record includes details on paper quality, binding, reproduction fidelity, or the exact number of images. Fitzroy 1974 lists 184 pages; Old Vintage Melbourne does not list a page count. These gaps are not flaws in the books, but they are limits on what can be compared here. If those factors are decisive for you, look for a preview or ask the store for more information before purchasing.



